Over and over again, Liquid Hip nails it! http://www.liquidhip.com/
To steal a line from McDonald's, it seems that the writers at Liquid Hip definitely "know what good is." I could not agree more with their reviews of the books, films and music I already know about. And, most of the things I didn't know about previously look like ones I would enjoy.
I am consistently impressed with the people, places and things they choose to review and the writing is top notch. If you haven't heard of the site yet, I highly suggest reading it ASAP.